Hedge funds are increasingly eyeing private credit as a competitive arena to challenge private equity firms, similar to their venture into venture capital over the past decade. Following the global financial crisis, private equity firms and specialist shops have expanded into private credit as banks reduced lending to lower-rated and smaller companies.
The Attraction of Private Credit
The potential for new capital in private credit is appealing; however, the asset class presents significant technical and operational challenges that many hedge funds may not be equipped to handle. David Nable, managing director of Arcesium (the non-investment technology division of D.E. Shaw), emphasized the need for careful navigation in this space. In an interview with Institutional Investor, he stated, “Getting this wrong” could lead to serious repercussions with investors and regulators alike. He noted, “It’s like, okay, this makes sense as an investment strategy, but how do we make sure we can actually do it in a proper and controlled way?”
Trends in the Market
Despite being in the early stages, Nable noted that every hedge fund manager with at least $5 billion in assets that Arcesium has engaged with about private credit is either already participating or actively exploring entry into the market. This trend reflects a broader convergence of public and private investing, where the distinctions between the two are increasingly blurred.
Notable firms like D.E. Shaw, J.P. Morgan, and Blackstone are significant players in the private credit market, with Blackstone Credit & Insurance managing $418 billion in private credit assets and D.E. Shaw offering private credit funds since 2008. Nable pointed out that “all of them are touching this in some way, shape, or form,” with some private equity firms having funds that invest in both public fixed income and private credit, shifting between the two depending on available opportunities.
Challenges Ahead
Entering the private credit market requires substantial investment in technology and operational infrastructure. Some hedge funds believe they need to raise at least $300 million for a standalone fund, considering the costs associated with upgrading systems for private credit investment.
Nable highlighted that this necessity is prompting asset management firms to reevaluate their operating models. “It’s causing the leadership of the firm to really think through how are they going to do this at scale to still be an institutional-quality firm,” he said. However, he cautioned that some hedge funds may merely be “chasing the hot trend” without the necessary credibility or experience in the segment.
Despite these challenges, hedge funds with a solid track record in credit investment possess natural opportunities to transition from bank loans to private credit. There is significant demand for these strategies; according to a survey by BNP Paribas, credit—both public and private—was the second most popular hedge fund strategy among allocators as of September. Currently, private credit strategies total approximately $1.7 trillion, as reported by Preqin.
Key Players and Strategies
Several hedge funds have already begun offering private credit products, including recognized credit investors such as Hildene Capital, King Street Capital, and LibreMax Capital. Third Point has also indicated that it is raising funds for a dedicated private credit strategy. Nable believes that credit portfolio managers and analysts possess the necessary skills to pivot to private credit; however, he warned that a significant leap in underlying infrastructure is required to support such a transition.
Operational Infrastructure
The operational aspects of private credit differ vastly from traditional liquid bonds. For instance, private loans lack real-time market feeds typically available through platforms like Bloomberg, making price determination challenging. Nable explained that while standardized data feeds facilitate profit and loss calculations and investor reporting in public markets, private loans require negotiation and origination between parties, complicating the process.
Hedge funds need robust operational infrastructures to monitor aspects like collateral and security clauses. “If you’re making a private loan to a private company, how are you monitoring those covenants?” Nable asked, emphasizing that what appears attractive on the investment side can become complicated operationally.
The Future of Hedge Funds in Private Credit
Despite these hurdles, hedge funds have a longstanding tradition of successfully navigating new and complex financial instruments. Some have achieved remarkable success by identifying early opportunities that less adaptable managers missed. For multistrategy hedge fund managers, the transition to private credit may be more straightforward due to existing sophisticated infrastructures that can accommodate these strategies.
For others, private credit may simply be a rebranding of strategies they have historically executed under different labels, such as specialty finance or mezzanine financing. Many managers have been involved in collateralized loan obligations (CLOs) for years, and these investments are now classified as private credit to align with current market trends.
As hedge funds continue to explore private credit, the industry may witness a significant shift in investment strategies and competitive dynamics, paving the way for new opportunities and challenges in this burgeoning sector.
Related topics: